poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 11501–11520 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Caducus on A moment, homeward by ecargo 25 Jan 2006, 7:35 AM
Sonnet like and an eye debut from you to me. Good first impression
Caducus on In praise of racism by INTRANSIT 25 Jan 2006, 7:33 AM
Different in style from you and the wit mixes well with the wisdom. I think the link from poin tot point needs a tidy though (example: their secret dimples until the lightbulb is screwed in Szechuan Some novel lines / expression use in this.
ALChemy on A Book's Plight by amanda_dcosta 25 Jan 2006, 7:28 AM
"Everyone's a book of blood; whenever we're opened we're red." -Clive Barker from The Books of Blood. Kinda comes across as a nice kids poem. So in that way I don't mind the simpler rhymes :)
Joe-joe replying on The True Fate of Humpty Dumpty by Joe-joe 25 Jan 2006, 7:09 AM
Very constructive comments ecargo. You're absolutely right about the NR coming out of nowhere... I actually wrote the last 4 lines first while sitting at my desk this morning. Don't ask me why but the Humpty Dumpty and Three Blind Mice thing just popped into my mind...that's kind of how it is with most of what I write. Interesting image but I felt myself straining to fit it within the context of a story...another common occurrence with regard to my writing. Again, I appreciate your thoughtful suggestions. Joe
ecargo on A Book's Plight by amanda_dcosta 25 Jan 2006, 6:51 AM
Amanda D'Costa! You stick with the metaphor all the way through and obviously put time into the meter and rhyme scheme, and the story/voice is nice. Simple is good, but the endstopped rhymes are too basic (for me anyway). I like simple rhymes too, but if there isn't some interesting language/imagery for contrast, they usually fall flat. A good example is Frost's most famous, "Nothing Gold Can Stay"--the rhymes are simple as can be, as is the meter (both of which absolutely fit the poem), but the language is so lyrical and fresh and the images so strong and original that the simple rhymes become part of the poem's strength). Stretch a bit. You've obviously got the interest and willingness to think about what you write--now take it to the next step. Which poets do you like to read? What is it about their work that works for you? That's always a good place to start.
ALChemy on The True Fate of Humpty Dumpty by Joe-joe 25 Jan 2006, 6:43 AM
Fascinating. This would be a great introduction to a story.
ALChemy replying on A Schizophrenic by amanda_dcosta 25 Jan 2006, 6:39 AM
Hopefully not infamous though. I had a psychologist tell me that she'd never met anyone more stable and with such inner peace. I thought, geeze lady you're more messed up than I am.
ecargo on The True Fate of Humpty Dumpty by Joe-joe 25 Jan 2006, 6:36 AM
Almost there Joe. Consider losing some of the modifiers (neatly, old abandoned--why not just abandoned?--restful (not that restful if you're up listening to the trains), etc.. Why "inexplicably" makes its (no apos. for the possessive "its"). "feel life in the ground beneath you" is nice. Needs more buildup/connection to the nursery rhyme aspects--they seem to come out of nowhere.
amanda_dcosta replying on A Schizophrenic by amanda_dcosta 25 Jan 2006, 5:31 AM
Ha ha ha..... Shrink he is! He says that its because of me he's landed up here. While I say that I'm his bystander, and that he's the patient who claims to be a doc. All the same, he's the one who signed me onto this site, posting my first poem here. I suppose he plans to study characters like you (through my membership) and then present a paper on his study. Look out for your name in the International journals of Psychiatry. You could be famous. Think about it....your path to fame.......
ALChemy replying on A Schizophrenic by amanda_dcosta 25 Jan 2006, 5:13 AM
He's a shrink? Cool, maybe he can cure some of us. Welcome to the cuckoos nest known as poemranker my dear.
ALChemy replying on When God is Needed No More by ALChemy 25 Jan 2006, 4:54 AM
Thank God you spent some time in luke warm NC. before heading north to Alaska. The temperature shock between Arabia and Alaska might have given you permanent Katharine Hepburn shakes.
amanda_dcosta on Insanity by Lifeboatman 25 Jan 2006, 12:17 AM
Poetry-wise, this might be good (still, I'm not saying it is), but matter-wise, it stinks!
Alizarin_Crimson on Unfortunate Lover by elderking 24 Jan 2006, 10:57 PM
Nice...I think you need to get rid of some pronouns, clean it up a little. I really like the concept, and the rhyme.
amanda_dcosta replying on When God is Needed No More by ALChemy 24 Jan 2006, 10:56 PM
You been to Shimla, or to India for that matter?
amanda_dcosta replying on When God is Needed No More by ALChemy 24 Jan 2006, 10:54 PM
I've been to Shimla last year and shivered terribly even with the umpteen amount of clothing and sitting near the heaters. Didn't even venture out into the knee deep snow, to keep myself alive..... and still returned with a lung infection.... can't think how one can tolerate cold for long. I still love the snow, though.
zodiac replying on When God is Needed No More by ALChemy 24 Jan 2006, 9:24 PM
It's an adventure, like going to Shimla. Tonight it's only -2 centigrade. We're not in Fairbanks or the North Slope, where it's been -42C (-44F) all day.
elderking on A Sheep’s Wish by Dovina 24 Jan 2006, 9:20 PM
I liked this alot. Very good.
AuntyM replying on In praise of racism by INTRANSIT 24 Jan 2006, 8:54 PM
lol.
The poem is well written... though it gave me the idea of Dr. Jeckyl and Mr. Hyde. Well written and a good theme.
amanda_dcosta replying on When God is Needed No More by ALChemy 24 Jan 2006, 7:57 PM
Alaska? What's up with you in Alaska.... in winter? Huh, I'm feeling chill here with a mild mild winter, and to hear of someone going to Alaska freezes me. Or is is that cold as I imagine it to be?