amanda_dcosta
replying on Rancor by Dovina
26 Jul 2008, 8:14 AM
Where inthe world is rockmage , btw? I dont see him around.
I like everything except from "plot" to "fans". It has a great beat.
Really, is it true? (blush)
Please try reading it again without the tarnishment of indulgent optimism, striving to find essences within it that might, with forthright effort, yield its pungent insights.
Caducus,
Very nice! Touching but not overly sentimental or "easy". I'm not sure about the various winds, but the imagery is interesting and "comfortable". The progression toward sadness comes through strongly, and so does the loneliness of dealing with Downs Syndrome. It has a clean, natural, "unpoetic" feel, which is a very good thing! Great job.
Lose, Lose, Lose, Fail
I stopped reading halfway through.
A lovely read.
Interesting.
Am left wondering what this 'what you' is about ...
Hi D. i remember cheering for you on your 200th poem, and here I see you've done another 100. Way to go girl. But what is this I read 'Amanda Dcosta has gone to heaven'? LOL. I was highly amused with that statement.
Ok... guess its time for Amanda Dcosta to step down from heaven and return to our PR World. You guys have been missing me for long..... Hello everyone... good to see you all. Cheers to PR. I'm back !!!
What you need to figure out the correct form of a sestina. fail.
GOD YOU SUCK WHO THE FUCK DO YOU THINK YOU ARE I LIKED IT A LOT
Yes. You're the protagonist. And Dovina plays the object of your drooping desires. I, on the other hand, am but a humble prune.
Where the heck is GUD anyway? I liked 20% of it and that's a lot. Be like Homer, I say, write for absolutely no reason at all and try to sell nothing.
Becoming more like willow than oak is very Dao and very cool.
Verse 2 displays drunkenness; please proofread.
Verse 5 is a thing I learned 20 years ago. But Verse 6 blows it.
The final verse is a disappointment to a good poem. Goals should always be subject to change.
Pardon my butting in, but it really ought to go somewhere beyond "failure" in the last verse. For starters dump the two semicolons and the quotes, also the colon. Cool if you're making movies now; if so, a bit more process please.
Thanks :)
Any thoughts on where else you would have liked to see it go, or questions you would have liked answered?
Pretty good flow but ending too soon.