poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 28761–28780 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

arduinn on Wedding Day by Caducus 12 Jun 2004, 8:51 AM
Brought up nice images when I read this but I have to agree with the things Intransit pointed out...
Shuushin on Lost by arduinn 12 Jun 2004, 8:44 AM
This would be better for a verb tense sweep. "Often I sit alone and wondered" "What does he has that Dad didn't?" stuff like that.
Shuushin replying on Untitled 48 by TLRufener 12 Jun 2004, 8:22 AM
Btw - I bet you could do this with less than half the words. I don't mean this as a dig in anyway, but after reading all of your poems (here, and there) I really think it would make them stronger. (please, don't throw that shoe)
Shuushin on Untitled 48 by TLRufener 12 Jun 2004, 8:16 AM
Ahah! I know what it is! it is a "riddle". Or it could also be a pen.
Chasz Misleading on Untitled 48 by TLRufener 12 Jun 2004, 8:14 AM
looking but never seeing?
TLRufener on To Mother by lynnstratton 12 Jun 2004, 7:20 AM
Beautiful. I love the imagery. Very touching.
arduinn replying on Fool by arduinn 11 Jun 2004, 11:49 PM
i'll do that.. but give me some time ya.. thanx
wilco replying on The Ocean Prefers A Sunset by wilco 11 Jun 2004, 11:23 PM
First, thanks for the critique and I think (hope) that the writers block has been lifted. Second, you're right about the little things...just a little problem I have (as discussed with Shin Shuu somewhere on this page. I've got to work on that. Third, with the last sentence, i just couldn't get it to sound right putting the 'she' in there. Fourth, I was just happy not to get a "Personally, I honestly don't think you'll ever be any good at writing poetry. Poets are born not made. You can improve, but only so far. You're poetically tone deaf." That stings. But I'll keep your suggestions in mind, for sure...and thanks.
zodiac replying on A Strenuous Recollection by Doug 11 Jun 2004, 10:56 PM
For horus8 and Shardik to "69" would require an extra mouth and set of genitalia, as well as some kind of sharklike cartilaginous spine. You would find it interesting, no doubt, but I'm afraid you'd never be able to see Cirque de Soliel the same way afterward.
zodiac replying on The Gray Idea by Doug 11 Jun 2004, 10:52 PM
"I wrote this poem in X minutes, therefore its immune to your criticism" is the buncombe dodge of an inverterate guffer.
zodiac replying on A Strenuous Recollection by Doug 11 Jun 2004, 10:37 PM
Shut up. Or, even better - since you're not going to follow my advice, anyway - learn to fucking type. And incidentally: "Torper" is correctly spelled "Torpor." Almost all of your commas require spaces after. Dashes, when used properly, should either be doubled (word--word) or spaced (word - word). As none of yours are used correctly, I don't think you need to worry about that part yet. "Lose" should be "loose." This poem is rather crappy - mostly because of your last line, but at least ten percent because of the idiotic comments with which you've besmeared this site today. Hey, and here's a prognostication for you: Doug: Fuck you. I know as much about writing as you! Jaime zodiac: Not. I have a Master's in Poetry from an accredited Poetry School, and besides I don't give a fuck what you think about writing or anything else for that matter, no returns. Doug: Stuffy intellectual elitist! You're what's wrong with poemranker and btw I gave all your poems zeros. Jaime zodiac: cock. Doug [a week later, at most]: ...
zodiac replying on The Gray Idea by Doug 11 Jun 2004, 10:21 PM
Are you a great ape trained to roughly approximate human typing?
zodiac replying on A Strenuous Recollection by Doug 11 Jun 2004, 10:20 PM
Is English your second language?
god'swife on fire has its own logic by impert&ent 11 Jun 2004, 8:39 PM
There's something innocent and frail about this poem, probably the honesty and use of everyday words. Lovely, your poem. She's got a few problems but they're small. Is this a first edit?
Doug replying on A Strenuous Recollection by Doug 11 Jun 2004, 8:29 PM
I would pull those hip-huggers down to your ankles and take your ass cherry,if you still had your's!-which you hav'nt had since you were ten!
Shuushin on Fool by arduinn 11 Jun 2004, 8:26 PM
Wow. This one is getting lots of traffic, isn't it? Never a bad thing. I'd like to see this expanded; fleshed out a bit - and it will be better for it.
god'swife replying on The Ocean Prefers A Sunset by wilco 11 Jun 2004, 8:20 PM
Much. some redundances you really should keep an eye out for: 'dancing waltzes...' the waltzes suggests dancing already, you might consider leaving the dancing out, helps with the flow of the image. 'and hoping for an evening rain to fall' Rain falls, everybody knows that so again, you could make things prettier by leaving '...to fall' out of it. Small little things make all the difference. Like Nanas embroidered napkin tucked under the silverware, or cleaning the mirror in the bathroom. I love the second stanza, the relationship between birth and death. Try not to use 'her' twice in one sentence if you can help it. the her in the final sentence is uncertain, which girl are you longing for? That last sentence could use 'She' at the beginning. Real good. Nice job.
Doug replying on A Strenuous Recollection by Doug 11 Jun 2004, 8:20 PM
Nice use of"pining"and"conveniently""godesses husband". Do me one favor?Suck one more penis before you go back to Nordstoms-please?
Doug replying on A Strenuous Recollection by Doug 11 Jun 2004, 7:56 PM
thanks "god'swife" I looked those words up myself.Da ha da ha.
Doug replying on The Gray Idea by Doug 11 Jun 2004, 7:50 PM
My ego almost said thanks.