mikejedw
on #9 by mikejedw
21 May 2002, 8:17 AM
Ah, comments on comments! You've been really busy, man--this is pretty great. Anyway, the numbering is there because I tend not to like giving haiku titles. I think, in larger poems, that I've actually written titles that are longer than haiku. It just seems overwhelming for such a short poem.
"Inhaled," to my ear, is two syllables, but you do raise an interesting point. I've long wondered whether "fire" is properly one or two syllables--the triphthong of "ire" makes for a very long vowel sound (long in the classical prosody sense) and can, in some dialects, sound much better broken in two. In fact, in the Carolinas, many "r" triphthongs, such as "there," come across as two syllables--"they-air." I make use of this ambiguity with "fire" in my haiku, "Fireflies."
Wow... some really nice ideas...
maybe if you were prettier and didn't whine so much. Really, there is nothing less attractive than pathetic girl poetry. Try growing a beard.
I hate to repeat myself, but the last two lines don't seem to carry through the theme, but introduce two entirely new ones (purity, mother and child) that aren't explored very much. It feels like a sudden change of direction right before the end.
Er, have you thought of posting these as separate poems? that would make commenting and voting a bit easier, especially since they vary so much in style. I'm going to vote/comment separately-
i) Love the wordplay, but the last line is kind of a letdown. I think it might be better without that line entirely. Still, an 8.
ii) 7.
iii)er, I don't quite get it. also, what do you mean by "make the nut"? 4.
iv) I like it, but I don't see how the last stanza relates to the rest of it. I do like the last stanza, it just seems to be about someting else entirely. 7.
I really enjoyed this whimsical poem. thanks for posting it
beg pardon? I liked the imagery until I got to the emerald.. what's the point? that an emerald is the key to your happiness? if that's so, you're just demonstrating the worst shallowness I've evern seen..
awkward.. too much metaphor ruins the mood.
love it.. quiet table is a terrific bit, very expressively minimalistic
Ohhh, I know this feeling. There's something about formal poetry that propels us through the writing of a poem, a birth-like struggle. This is a very funny piece of ars poetica, particularly the abundance (and alternation) of feminine rhymes from a "female poet".
wonderful
whats the spoon?? I wonder
This reminds me far too much of things I've seen and is well done. It stumbles a little in the 4th stanza, but nicely done overall.
Hmm.. I wonder if I know this person, too?
hrmmm...the words that comet to mind while reading this poem, include: SAP, CLICHE, SUPERFICIAL....you can imagine the rest. it feels like you're just saying someone else's words here..your emotions are valid, but you should find a way to put them into words people haven't heard before. try putting your emotions into a context...a fan loving a rock star, a dancer falling in love with a client, poor with rich...be creative, and make me interested in your love
hrmmm...the words that comet to mind while reading this poem, include: SAP, CLICHE, SUPERFICIAL....you can imagine the rest. it feels like you're just saying someone else's words here..your emotions are valid, but you should find a way to put them into words people haven't heard before. try putting your emotions into a context...a fan loving a rock star, a dancer falling in love with a client, poor with rich...be creative, and make me interested in your love