poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 7561–7580 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Ranger on Plastic Posies by BleedingRose 16 May 2006, 4:44 AM
This is damn funny, there are a few rhythmic inconsistencies but if they were ironed out this would be excellent. And for the first time in years I don't mind the rhyme of heart/part, for that you get bonus points.
Edited, still not happy with it but it'll progress. I plan to take the first stanza and selected lines from elsewhere to make a crucifixion poem too, particularly given what Imp told me about 'tree' also meaning the cross on which Christ died.
That's okay, I think this one will evolve in gentle stages. I'm really trying to find out how far I can stretch the reader without losing them. As it stands, it's way wide of the mark.
amanda_dcosta on The Bleeding Rose by BleedingRose 15 May 2006, 11:10 PM
Bleeding Rose, there are quite contridictory ideas coming through. MAybe , you should edit it to either a love mood or to a hate mood. By you mixing the two, we are not sure what you want to emphasise on. Being specific gives you additional points. And I really wonder who this jerk is, going around giving a zero to all your poems. Maybe he needs a double dose of his own medicine.
amanda_dcosta replying on Forgiveness by Niphredil 15 May 2006, 11:02 PM
Dovina, I'd rather say that, first of all, most people don't ask for forgiveness, or don't want to admit their wrong and sorry. Doing this is a noble act of courage and love. Niphredil, this is a lovely poem, and I esp like the third verse...'Struggling against each other; strangling each other, Till nothing more was left but a dull throbbing void.' You have quite a few good phrases here. Good work!
amanda_dcosta on Cat Feet by Niphredil 15 May 2006, 10:52 PM
Ha ha ha. This is what I think you would call selective deafness and being paranoid at the same time. Ah yes, scrolling down, I see that my impression has already been impressed upon by others. This is lovely. I wonder how many of us fit into this category. You ofcourse, have qualified.
amanda_dcosta on After Rain by Niphredil 15 May 2006, 10:43 PM
Lovely. I just have a vague idea of what a sonnetis especially the rhyming scheme, which I think you have stuck to, and apart from that, the content is good. I especially liked the third verse, the line...'A holocaust of car exhaust as brutal boots crashed down'.
amanda_dcosta on Nightfall by Niphredil 15 May 2006, 10:31 PM
I think this is well written and I especially like the last lines of each stanza, esp. the repetitions.
amanda_dcosta replying on The Prodigal Daughter by Dovina 15 May 2006, 10:23 PM
Edna, I think you aught to give a bit of consideration to the content of the poem, and the depth of emotion related to it, rather than only to nit-picking punctuations.
amanda_dcosta on The Prodigal Daughter by Dovina 15 May 2006, 10:19 PM
Very heartfelt and beautiful. I'd like it too if there was enough punctuation. And the partial rhyme scheme is distracting. Nevertheless, I think you deserve nothing less than an 8.
Hi Ranger, truthfully, I still don't get what your poem is about. Having a rough idea is not enough. Sorry to disappoint. I refrain from voting.
amanda_dcosta replying on A Snap Shot by amanda_dcosta 15 May 2006, 9:57 PM
I know what you are trying to say Al. And I know it isn't my best. But when words flow like this one, I believe that it doesn't necessarily have to be my best, and hence I post it. Like everybody else, I too face what is 'writer's block' and am so distracted at the moment as I'm going through my next phase of life.... have to shift from here,where I really love being. Packing up is hard. Maybe I should write some thing about it. May be.
Dovina on With a pithy stroke by D. $ Fontera 15 May 2006, 7:32 PM
The last line seems to say the same thing twice, which, in a haiku, is far too many.
Ranger replying on George and Samson by Edna Sweetlove 15 May 2006, 5:39 PM
And I had the unnerving feeling that you were going to include a line that ended with 'front'. Can't think what you might rhyme it with though...
Ranger on George and Samson by Edna Sweetlove 15 May 2006, 5:36 PM
Having just borne witness to your incredible roundup of the limericks on here, the least I can do is leave a comment on one of your poems. And here it is: This poem is a golden opportunity to rhyme 'Samson' with 'ram some'. I'll leave you to decide what was rammed, and where.
Good. Original rhyming asnd scansion. talented.
Dave says this stinks.
Edna Sweetlove on Perversions by razorgrin 15 May 2006, 5:16 PM
I give up.this is rubbish.
Not good. Where were you when the humour tablets were handed out?
Edna Sweetlove on Charles by neurula 15 May 2006, 5:15 PM
What is the joke, dear?