Ranger
on Numbers In Heaven by Dovina
13 Mar 2006, 7:58 AM
With the exception of 'unmatched and unmatchable' this made me think of The Island. Which, although I was sceptical, wasn't a terrible film.
'Called, with affection, odd'
Marvellous. 9
Could do without so many uses of "my."
Awesome. Stanzas 2, 3 and 4 rocked my world, as did the final two lines.
It's been too long since I last read your stuff.
Brief, simple and fairly effective.
The title was the best part though.
Vivid! Very few poems actually take me to the scene; this one is an exception. Once again I think your word choice is impeccable...no fault with this one whatsoever. Stanza 3 was great and stanza 4 was even better!
Ha! I never get these though, either my email is too obscure, or the hotmail junk filter is supreme ¬.¬
Pretty nifty, a decent tale of the human condition. It certainly takes courage to write something this lengthy and search for plenty enough rhymes without turning the reader off; you manage it very well.
Stanza 5 was the best.
Decent fragment, the idea's pretty good - but I'm curious as to where you're going with it.
Kind of defiant which is nice to see. The problem with it, though, is that it's all been written before. For example, 'broken dreams' makes me assume you listen to Green Day. If you could make this something new and innovative it would work well.
Either there's a hidden genius in this that I am blind to (entirely possible)...or you really do need to make some serious grammatical corrections. 'Four walls fortifying the realm(s?)' is good, 'make it to yell' is not. 'To yell' is the infinitive, and so in this context shouldn't be used with 'make it', which is present active. The three lines after that...I don't really know what they mean.
'The nature's statue that which bonds' could work, but needs punctuating. '...statue - that which bonds...' or something like that. The rest of the stanza sort of work although 'crinkle' would sound better as 'crinkling'.
Stanza 3 - 'migrates' and 'divulges', as you are talking about a first person singular subject for both. I like the ending to it though.
But I still have to ask - what does it all mean?
Not bad, but it needs work. Stanza 1: First line is great but would profit from more imaginative language (give a bit of colour to it). Line two "your" should be "you're". "In confused nature" sounds too much like you're trying to be pseudo-philosophical.
Stanza 2: again the first line isn't bad, but it gets meaningless with the second line. 'When together we're apart...' is fine, but 'when together we're apart and away' loses any real sense. It seems like you meant something else but didn't quite make it work as you intended.
Stanza 3 is a little cliched - try and replace 3/4 of the lines with something a little more original.
Stanza 4 is good.
Hope these suggestions are of some use.
Dear Dovina,
I thought I had implied the causes of Aggapus's problems, with 'brought forth a dream' and 'dallied inthoughts quite unreal' but here is another stanza
he learned about poetry, painting and joy,
and even today he still looks like a boy.
He wandered, unknowing, far out of the world;
as his dreamy illusions of wonder unfurled
he lived like a phantom of ardent belief
too lost in the beauty to see his own grief.
Well I don't want to see Brokeback Mountain either, but the poem could do with a little more thought, some rhyme or rhythm, or beautiful language.
Read this aloud before you post it next time - sounds quite improper - does it not? Thought and emotion are placed well - but grammar and meter is quite lacking.
Jubilant dolphin? Passionate bird? Giraffe's head?
Erase this whole thing and start over.Sorry so harsh - but this really needs work.
Another good one, nice title...my favorite line is one of the repeated lines, "flashing lights become a string of pearls," because its so gosh darn purdy. back to homework.
thank you, my good friend. sorry that i've been away for a while...ive lost inspiration recently, as well as being buried in homework. ill be back soon, though.
in my mind as i read this everything is still a blur
i like poems that tell a story and this one was very good. I enjoyed it alot.