on bacardi, tall glass, lots of ice, diet coke by Skamper
11 Jul 2007, 9:50 AM
"mighty" is just there to get a lucky 7, it seems. In what way is water frosty?
on Blanket Weed by Christof
11 Jul 2007, 9:57 AM
I think you can lose "First."
Comma after water.
The green fleece image for a fish stuffed and mounted on the wall works well, but the complex way you develop it will leave some readers wondering what you mean.
Comma after water.
The green fleece image for a fish stuffed and mounted on the wall works well, but the complex way you develop it will leave some readers wondering what you mean.
on On and On and On by MacFrantic
11 Jul 2007, 10:08 AM
Yes, it's an undisciplined rant. But I like:
So I'm a disaster
A miserable hackneyed bore
And my mind's a whore
Describes a "poet" writing to please masses.
So I'm a disaster
A miserable hackneyed bore
And my mind's a whore
Describes a "poet" writing to please masses.
on Coffee House Adjacent by Enkidu
13 Jul 2007, 8:49 AM
I think it would be stronger with fewer words. "then to" "to each other" "there is" - What do these add?
on some deleted poem
11 Jul 2007, 4:47 PM
The process of writing this kind of poem is in answering the question, âWhat is it that I feel?â Expression through art is an exploration of your experience. But instead, you have tried to make an emotion fit a category. If you want to express the terror that something causes, for example, you should not give it an epithet like âdreadfulâ for that describes the emotion instead of expressing it. Descriptions express emotions only in the sense that they clarify by generalizing. They groups a particular thing together with other things of the same general sort. Expression, by contrast, marks the distinctions between different things that might be described in the same way. To express your anger is to clarify it in all its particularity. The poet, grappling with a certain emotion says, âI want to get this clear.â She does not want a thing of a certain kind; she wants a certain thing. I could have handed you the cliché, âShow, donât tell,â but that would be doing the thing Iâm asking you not to.
I donât know if any of this interests you, but it has helped me to know how I feel about it.
I donât know if any of this interests you, but it has helped me to know how I feel about it.
on Dying Candle by cheese.doodles
22 Jul 2007, 7:33 PM
A good metaphor for something, but what? I can think of several twists. As it stands, you only describe the dying candle.
on The End of The Deathly Hallows by John Rambo
22 Jul 2007, 7:34 PM
Potter is overblown! A good way to get kids to read though.
on The Time-Winder's Lullaby by PsydewaysTears
17 Jul 2007, 3:29 PM
How can a sin know anything? Otherwise nice.
on some deleted poem
4 Aug 2007, 9:59 AM
I think your attitude may grow younger; I hope so. So keep pressing the strings, making the chords less clumsy, and unlike most people as they age, keep forgiving. Oh, yes, try to make you poetry less clumsy too. Best of luck.
on Beggar by MacFrantic
4 Aug 2007, 10:03 AM
Please stop writing about this woman on a bicycle, crossing America coast to coast, now three-fourths of the way from Virginia to California. I can relate to much of the sentiment in this. What are you riding?
on To a Grunting Man on the Train by Christof
4 Aug 2007, 10:07 AM
I am with you until the last three lines. The ending switches topic too much and is unclear.
on Sadist by PoetryIsDead
4 Aug 2007, 10:13 AM
Good title for this.
on Under the rain by Prince of Void
8 Aug 2007, 7:53 PM
One of your best.
on Passive Birth Control by http://mulberryfairy
24 Aug 2007, 3:30 PM
You use some unusual words: devotement (devotion, perhaps); devout as a noun (but it works); redounded (a more common word might do better). Overall, it's a novel thing and therefore good.
on Foreign film by richa
24 Aug 2007, 3:37 PM
Enjamb if you want to, but I think a period is needed after flickering. Perhaps a title about subject matter; I know it's a film, but does that really matter? I think the second verse is better than the first because of the nebulous fascist reference.
on some deleted poem
26 Aug 2007, 8:13 PM
I like it all but the last line. It seems too obvious.
Do you mean wolves or wolf's?
And what reference is there for "beast of war"?
Then there's that old rock-tossing machine, the trebuchet, coming in at the end.
Still, with all these difficulties, I get a feel for what you're saying, and like it. I shouldn't do this, but I'm voting a 9.