on Little Girl by hbhpoems
30 Jun 2004, 11:16 AM
spelling and grammar would help this. still too much telling for me.
on Fumble at the Lounge by Rodavlas
28 Jun 2004, 7:47 PM
The metaphor is somewhat interesting, but overall it doesn't have enough rhythm for me; the lines jerk from one to the next. The half-rhyme of 'couch' and 'pout' really doesn't work for me. I think the poem could be more interesting if you explored the metaphor a bit more directly and left the broad statements to be assumed.
Hope this is somewhat helpful...
Hope this is somewhat helpful...
While I'm sure this is a poem about yourself and all the abuse you have suffered, you're not doing a very good job of expressing it. For one, it's a very tired theme, and there's nothing new in your treatment. For two, it's pure showing-not-telling, and while there are exceptions to that rule as any other, this is not one of them. For three, there's very little flow to the piece.
on My first Haiku by DJCopasetic
29 May 2004, 7:40 PM
this more properly goes in the 'metaku' category.
cute, though.
cute, though.
on Perversions 7: Viva Las Naked by razorgrin
22 May 2004, 3:59 PM
I had to look up DVDA. I have to say.
replying on sum of squares by nentwined
17 May 2004, 9:00 PM
glad to hear it. you a sagittarius? ;)
replying on Truckers should not be poets by INTRANSIT
16 May 2004, 7:59 PM
I was probably just reading too much into it, then, as it's self-referential at least regarding the poetry, I thought perhaps the "my reason for being here" was referring to p/r--especially made sense with the jeers and whatnot.
on Truckers should not be poets by INTRANSIT
16 May 2004, 2:33 PM
The rhythm does seem a bit off, but villanelles are like that even when they're spot on, I think. You use some very simple rhymes, perhaps ironically, but that doesn't make them hurt less. I like the two lines you've used to repeat, and I really like that you alternate the leading. Negative points (in my book) for anything that asks for the context of poemranker. But. Dunno. For the form, and for what you're saying, I think you've done a decent job. Bonus for giving me fat to chew. This'll sit in my favorites for a bit regardless.
replying on selfhood, through extrospection by nentwined
10 May 2004, 8:56 PM
kaolin fire.
Subjectivity only goes so far. This poem was good for me, in that it got some things out of me. But that doesn't make it a good poem, at least in the ranker sense. To my eyes. I suppose if other people like it, ... erm. I'll just leave this as confused. Ot something.
Thoughts not so much happen, lately.
Thoughts not so much happen, lately.
I'm glad it's not just me. People I think vote more my status than my poetry. Or something.
In my depression I felt it had to be crap.
Feeling somewhat better, I find it very interesting crap; the stacatto-like almost-flow is nice. Or almost nice. The message--over-simplistic, if there at all. La.
You're all too kind, even the 7.
In my depression I felt it had to be crap.
Feeling somewhat better, I find it very interesting crap; the stacatto-like almost-flow is nice. Or almost nice. The message--over-simplistic, if there at all. La.
You're all too kind, even the 7.
I suspect it may have to do with my sleep cycle and my caffeine cycle.