wFraser Allonby Q.C.w
on My Sister's a Ninja by fevriere
25 Mar 2004, 9:24 AM
Cripes!
Thanks, Shuushin, for looking in and commenting on both this and yesterday's submission.
I'll keep trying, but you're a hard man to please :-).
Some good tidbits; more clever than effective.
"On a Gethsemane of popcorn" is a nice line, but doesn't get the visual punch it should, I think, because popcorn needs to be doing something in this place (like being strewn on the ground or something) rather than being the place.
"salted phial" is a nice ryhme with smile, if slightly out of context -
overall, it shows a nice control of language - maybe shows -off- a bit too, but the subject isn't terribly appealing (personally) - it may find a market though since it's topical. Best be quick though.
2nd stanza has to go. What else you got?
the rest is very nice with some solid poetic language.
So, overall I like how you say it, but what you say isn't too engaging.
oh. close.
betrayal, suicide - so many poems to compete with and this one just gets trampled.
the tiny words that don't add value don't hurt this one as much because its a nice sentiment.
You could beef it up by trimming it down though - still - quite well done.
smells like a poem; a good approximation.
... something one might use to warm up to start writing a poem.
Start from the drop kick and go from there.
"ponder yet a second laughter screen" makes me struggle.
drawers boxers redundant, fine but as a rationalization to mirror words in the next few lines - no.
this smells synthetic somehow; strung together from random thoughts then a pasting of the first line to the last to imitate structure and - done. Thats what it looks like anyway.
aphoristic, and could be truth - but it's only a subset of a poem.
problem with this:
"As a mother intent on
With a million vows."
the language use with all those conjunctions, prepositions and simple verbs doesn't do this much help.
hmmmm.... some line breaks would give this a better flow.
Some fresh thoughts on a pretty common theme.
Some verbs would have been nice.
A toilet-approved Swiss army jodhpur of triumph -10-
Hey - not a bad hook. Could make a good song.
My favorite part was when you kinda summarized all your previous points at the end. That really drew it all together for me.
"You, a new flavor expanding
Across my windshield."
Richard, for this kind of [sadly very common] subject matter it needs to really stand out to, well, stand out.
Some good imagery here, but not truly striking.