poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 34681–34700 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

middenHeap replying on Lullaby by Goad 27 Jan 2004, 5:02 PM
Thank you. And thank you for leaving this comment, because I hadn't come across any of your pomes before. I've just spent the last two hours reading them, and it was an enormously enjoyable two hours.
zodiac on Murderers in the Tropics by Fear of Garbage 27 Jan 2004, 5:01 PM
Mon dieu! >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> "sleepy, safe and warm" could be different.
minus 8 for not being a haiku. Minus another 1 for not being very poetic or making any sense.
you delightful little gothic child you.
zodiac on Camera Obscura by Fear of Garbage 27 Jan 2004, 4:57 PM
I could tell you were a woman. Dickens could tell George Eliot was immediately, too, or so the anecdote goes. Are the leaves from O.Henry?
zodiac replying on Fastened to my belt by irishfolksuicide 27 Jan 2004, 4:51 PM
You're right.
middenHeap replying on Camera Obscura by Fear of Garbage 27 Jan 2004, 4:39 PM
z, I think I can tell she's a chick. I started with "Love in the Tropics" though, so I guess that's not fair. But I agree with all your other adjectives. You forgot "fuckin' good." F.o.G., do you know Martha Hollander? You might enjoy her. I like "eating my cake with a fork and grating" I don't get the connection between five leaves left and the camera obscura. Can you enlighten me--I hate feeling stupid. Oh, and fix the spelling of excellent.
"You are taking up my Oxygen, Nitrogen, Argon, you are taking up my arrogance." is great. The rest is (for you) mediocre.
Was the spelling of field really intentional? I agree with god'swife, the last line -- content of which is superb, no complaints there -- should be tidied up. If not by deleting the extra then, at least break it differently.
middenHeap replying on The Feild In Which I Live by Fear of Garbage 27 Jan 2004, 4:08 PM
because it is.
andrewjthomas on Cecelia by Nicholas Monson 27 Jan 2004, 4:06 PM
most excellent i think "missiles" does not fit but that's the only thing i can find fault with "An Audrey Hepburn with a Viking gene" is SUCH an inspired line, i love it
andrewjthomas on Darkness by Felzpoet 27 Jan 2004, 3:59 PM
not quite a sonnet - must be 14 lines also, needs iambic pentameter the repetition is forced and elementary however, you do make a nice turn at the end
andrewjthomas on Aphrodite (edited) by Caducus 27 Jan 2004, 3:57 PM
need to work on your iambic pentameter a bit also, it doesn't really speak to me, but i think that's just because i don't care much for this particular mythology
andrewjthomas on The woods house by zodiac 27 Jan 2004, 3:52 PM
wow, just wow i feel like a humble ass clown in comparison my one teeny tiny note would be that i enjoyed the breaks that spanned the stanzas and wished that all the stanzas did that going back and forth was only slightly jarring i think in general though, your breaks are great and really adds to the feel
-=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. on Winter by morffrom 27 Jan 2004, 3:44 PM
Ahh, Winturd. The white season; nestled moistly 'tween the green and the browne... Speaking of browne, I daresay your butterfly is not the only frozen tear in heaven. Have you not heard "The Winturd Tale of Sir Donald Nudesby"? It runs thus, in the Common Tongue... Footprints linger on the lawn Where Nudesby trod ere crack of dawn Then out beyond the seemly parts and in amongst the compost carts. There to clench in wooden shack Ere sweating brow gave way to cack And buttocks wiped with little care Leave brownly marks upon his chair. But footprints leave, and don't return And Nudesby's fate may cause concern Young children ought to shield their ears Whilst women fight to hold back tears: Through winturd night, and morning frost It seems that Nudesby has been lost 'tis little wonder that he froze - Sir Donald Nudesby wore no clothes!
andrewjthomas on Hollywood Blue by Mona Lisa 27 Jan 2004, 3:43 PM
First stanza - L4: personally I would change this to : And popsicle-peeled. L6&7: pink champagne AND fizzy pop seems like too much unless you add a but: They give her pink champagne But she asked for fizzy pop Second stanza is great Third stanza - L5: misspelling - fetal L6: "Father Figure" is WAY too obvious L7: this entire last line is also WAY too obvious and a bit of a let down for the culmination of this piece many people write poems about junkies and heroin this is a fairly decent portrayal of the starlett seduced by drugs i would just fix the few things i mentioned less is more, it really is
andrewjthomas replying on sunday morning precarious by andrewjthomas 27 Jan 2004, 3:26 PM
i replaced it with the virginia beach poem i got tired of waiting to post something and now that i know the strange smell comes from eating asparagus it just doesn't seem as cool anymore
uh...i like this one. Its kinda like a personal narative but, you know, like way better. BTW: where did your piss test go??? :)
irishfolksuicide replying on Fastened to my belt by irishfolksuicide 27 Jan 2004, 3:05 PM
The contrition is the remorse shown by the first person 'I', towards the priest.
lastobelus replying on Here In The Heart of Amber by Lenore 27 Jan 2004, 2:48 PM
ok, I retract my comment. I'm not sure why "keep" bothered me. Possibly because I'm insane?