poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 65481–65500 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

nentwined on Z higher of arts by ==Doylum 11 Sep 2002, 12:32 PM
several bits where the lines don't fit the form; rather hurts tromping through a limerick and you hit one of those bits.
nentwined on Tryst by <~> 11 Sep 2002, 12:30 PM
very nice. =) I haven't seen a limerick done "poetically" in my life, I think.
[mojo] on 22nd Anniversary by Frass 11 Sep 2002, 12:09 PM
I can smell those herbs. "Asurety surely", trips up the tongue but makes me smile. Like you say "vibrant", that's how i find the whole piece. 8.
[mojo] on Avian Child by Tekara 11 Sep 2002, 11:53 AM
Enjoyable. Excellent first two stanza's. I found the third weaker overall, I would think about cutting it. Just the last line jarred...I think the "not FAIR" exclamation sounds slightly juvenile. The poem said so much to me until then, that last line seemed to cheapen it. I find the scenario you have built, more than just... unfair...something stronger....cheated? 8.
poetandknowit on 9/11 by dougsoderstrom 11 Sep 2002, 11:53 AM
A 9/11 poem on 9/11 with another 9/11 poem somewhere in here written by the deevil himself. I think it rather bold to try to minimize such a hefty theme into such odd schematics. I wonder if other great tragedies like the holocaust and such went through a period where the writing was generic and over generalized before taking effect in a more personal sense and thus developing its own genre of quality (albeit depressing) literature.
beakism on 9/11 by dougsoderstrom 11 Sep 2002, 11:47 AM
nice non-haiku.
Frass replying on Gone Away by Christof 11 Sep 2002, 11:38 AM
Do you mean 'pretentious'?
some deleted user on Morning Glory by waltfreakinwhitman 11 Sep 2002, 11:11 AM
how is this still in the bottom 15?
Limness replying on Pigeons by Limness 11 Sep 2002, 10:52 AM
You are correct; it fixed it. Thanks.
Limness replying on At the Olde Absinthe by Limness 11 Sep 2002, 10:40 AM
Thank you.
maybe its all the acid in forever encraved on the memorial to abstinence that now stands on my spine, but not only did i get to the end of this own personal illiad, but i didn't even pay the usual attention to the overwhelming length...usually i get up and make a sandwich halfway through...either way, i shall finish off with a very much child-like "i likey the stuff, mommy"
beakism replying on Forbidden Love by beakism 11 Sep 2002, 10:34 AM
The pleasure is all mine.
god on None by poemreader 11 Sep 2002, 10:17 AM
Seems a little confused and confusing-have another go and see if you can understand it first !
nentwined on None by poemreader 11 Sep 2002, 10:16 AM
I'm confused. Oh, I see -- I was reading "two of four children, including me as one" to mean you were one of the two... which made the rest of the poem very skewed. The actual rhythm of the poem I find overly halting, stopstarting, and repetitive -- it drones. I'm left mildly curious as to what's happened to or with them.
nentwined on Lysander cried by bornagainpoet 11 Sep 2002, 10:13 AM
it's cute. If Lysander is someone I'm expected to know, I don't get it. If Lysander is you, my personal opinion is to keep personal names out of things. I can't really empathise with it when I'm being jolted out like that. Also, the scan/rhythm/flow/whatnot could use a little work; maybe just fixing the grammar or making a proper nod to it would do it.
god on Winter by morffrom 11 Sep 2002, 10:12 AM
Maybe its not quite a butterfly yet, still coming out of the chrysalis !-anyway the poet seems to be indicating that the premature death of any creature is a cause for sorrow, a buddhist credo of which even tarquin should be aware-I agree with him 8/10
god'swife on Forbidden Love by beakism 11 Sep 2002, 10:10 AM
This poem was awful, til the end. Then it became very funny. Thanks for pulling me in.
1. I didn't give you a three. Good try, though! 2. Haven't we been over this before? Last time I actually counted, fewer than 1/7 of my poemes made ANY REFERENCE to faeces at all. Yet this still seems to be the thrust of all your attacks and counterattacks. em erob uoy. 3. Don't you have anything to say in your defense? Can you do naught but fling tiresome accusations of fecal obsession? 4. Actually, you do come over to "my side" and "mess with me". Anyway I *am* letting you do what you do, you fanny. It's called CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM. I made a suggestion. If you're too much of a man to consider it then I guess you win.
beakism replying on The Writing Life by poetandknowit 11 Sep 2002, 10:00 AM
I'm not quite sure if you're being ironic. Whether or not you are, I think my comment was perfectly suited. You have to say 'unlucky' with proper emphasis on the 'l' and a smug chuckle during the 'ucky', rasing your eyebrows throughout; that way, you get the strongest feeling of 'I'm pissed off and you're pissing me off even more so now I'm going to break your face'.
poetandknowit replying on The Writing Life by poetandknowit 11 Sep 2002, 9:50 AM
I think the 3 is really quite significant and if you were really a master of symbolism you would see that this is a deep personal masterpiece. That is all I know how to write, perfect poems, it is in my blood. And Beaker, what the hell does that mean. Make a better comment when you finally read genius.