poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 10201–10220 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Wakeboarder20 replying on Revised Dream (Final Version) by Wakeboarder20 24 Feb 2006, 10:06 AM
I've revised it some. I doubt this will be my final revision because this is about my tenth revision so far. I would just like to know if you feel I'm going in the right direction. Thank you.
oneglove replying on Darker Days by oneglove 24 Feb 2006, 7:50 AM
yeah, i agree with you. the line is from lifestyles of the rich and famous, i put it there for unexplainable reasons. i was just having funw ith it but youre right, it takes a way from the poem. i'll get around to changing it but not right now.
smoofle on Beauty, sleeping by Ranger 24 Feb 2006, 7:16 AM
This is still my favourite of your early stuff...
smoofle on The Struggling Poet's Lament by Ranger 24 Feb 2006, 7:13 AM
I love it - but I think it needs tweaking, then I'll love it more. xxx
smoofle on Hailing Miriam by Ranger 24 Feb 2006, 7:12 AM
You'll get a 10 from me when you change the Lorelei line, Craigus. xxx
Mwahahahah! Archie! I'm here! Also... I'm so damn proud this poem is about me. Love you always xxx
Ranger replying on On Looking Back by Dovina 24 Feb 2006, 6:33 AM
"I once had a friend dressed in black" That wasn't so painful now, was it :p
Ranger on Darker Days by oneglove 24 Feb 2006, 6:29 AM
Crikey, where do I begin with this one? I really like this poem, the first and last stanzas shine very brightly for me. 'Caviar dreams' I swear I've seen before, which is a bit of a shame as it detracts slightly from the overall originality of the piece. The same applies to 'bleeding skies'; in my opinion the second stanza could do with a reworking to bring it to the standard of the other two. The final stanza is fantastic, perhaps 'I love you' should be in quote marks? 'Twin sapphires set in snow/Look like a murder scene'. 8 for now, with a rework of stanza two this will be at least a nine.
Okay, I like the idea at the core of this - positive poems are getting rarer by the day. However, when you get into the description it is very cliched and - dare I say it - lacking in a bit of imagination. As some advance warning, the 'love/above' rhyme is certain to lose you marks here (it is possible the most used phrase in the world of poetry, although run close by 'hate/fate'). Also, 'fields of love' really doesn't work. Although I know in a way what you're saying, it's totally nonsensical. Have a listen to 'Fields of Gold' (by the Police, just in case you haven't heard it) for an example of mastery of this sort of imagery. Essentially what I am trying to say here is that this poem will be very good if you can make it original. Read a lot of poetry on here and note all the recurring phrases/rhymes/images. Then avoid them like the plague. Your imagination will do the rest. I look forward to seeing any revisions of this.
Ranger replying on You by terbenaw 24 Feb 2006, 5:33 AM
Okay, I see you've changed 'velvety' now, I think it works better. Did you alter anything else? Now, you evidently want other people to comment/critique this, but I've had a look at your profile, and if the comment count includes comments on your own works (which I think it does), you've only made 5 comments on poems not by you. If you want others to make the effort on your poems, you have to first give them some feedback - even if it's just to say whether you liked/disliked their poems and why. You don't need to give a full-on analysis of a poem in order for the writer to appreciate you spending the time to look at their work. Right, I'm giving this an 8 because it has some very nice passages and is pretty well structured. I still don't like 'phosphorescent', but I'm sure not everyone will agree with me there. Peace
ALChemy replying on Just Desserts (for drnick) by ALChemy 23 Feb 2006, 6:27 PM
You're always welcome to blah blah on my poems as much as you like. Your critiques are among my favorites. "Who hasn't learned/that what is earned/might not be rewarded/but if forwarded [?]/may not come on schedule" is not a question but a description of the "fool" in stanza two. Unless your question is what do I mean by "forwarded". I just mean sent or given by that. As far as nature vs one man's peace of mind: If one man hates the sight of the moon should the moon be destroyed? "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy" Nature is far greater in scale than one man's needs. Since nature consists of the many, the one is always out numbered. The chalice/palace represents riches and divinity. "He's so focused on the chalice/palace -he might miss what he's won through his own efforts" is right on the mark. The needs of nature is the answer to why his needs aren't all fulfilled and so he should appreciate and seize the gifts and oppertunities that are given to him and not dwell too much on what he didn't get.
Scarlett on Edges by Blue Magpie 23 Feb 2006, 3:13 PM
I absolutely LOVE the beginning of this - the first two lines especially. You could make it tight with the examples and less attempt on the rhyme ~ this could be a beauty.
Scarlett on How Well I See by Blue Magpie 23 Feb 2006, 3:06 PM
For some reason, the Villanelle form scares the daylights out of me to attempt, but your poem flowed well and the repetition formed a circle around the meaning. Enjoyed and might inspire me to give the form a try!
Scarlett on The Acorn Daisies by MacFrantic 23 Feb 2006, 2:44 PM
Written in the harsh climate of beauty. Enjoyed this very much!
MacFrantic replying on Iron Sky by MacFrantic 23 Feb 2006, 1:42 PM
Actually, I was refering to satirist Neal Pollack. The lack of commas is intentional. Also, "burden of her foil" is taken in a figurative sense, hence her cursing the sky.
nentwined replying on First Unborn Sun by Been Here Before 23 Feb 2006, 11:58 AM
Actually, everything should just work now. You may need to log out and log back in. If you can't log out, try clearing your poemranker cookie.
nentwined replying on First Unborn Sun by Been Here Before 23 Feb 2006, 11:45 AM
The issues that were printed are still being sold, I believe -- http://nfg.ca/ -- but they're not doing any more. I had a parting of ways with them. On the other hand, I've got a new magazine that's going to open to submissions come July. Account info to come via email.
TLRufener replying on The Mirror by TLRufener 23 Feb 2006, 11:44 AM
I wrote this poem angered by mother once again ruining my weekend plans. The reflection is a metaphore for her always being there critisizing me.
zodiac replying on Nude Falling Down Staircase by zodiac 23 Feb 2006, 11:26 AM
Well, say context should be self-contained. When I write I find myself ballooning out-of-control out of the situation I've set out to describe. I wrote this as kind of my determination to not do that so much. re "dessert": yes. That's unconscionable. Maybe I should get away from the computer for a bit. It seems to be eating brain cells.
Been Here Before replying on First Unborn Sun by Been Here Before 23 Feb 2006, 11:23 AM
Thank you. This elliminates the "it" and I believe keeps the poem a little more to form. See what you think.