CommentsComments 27921–27940 back. Include replies to comments

poetandknowit on Toku by Bill Z Bub 21 Oct 2003, 7:16 PM
The fact that Z has to send/post a picture of the event for the poem to really to take hold hurts the poem. Maybe you could give the reader just a bit more to make it make sense of what and why it (i.e. “Nature” is being said. I am afraid that the name just doesn’t cut it. Of course, I am sure hatter’s hare will disagree, but what does she know, she only drinks pilsner. I think we get that idea when we look at the picture, but alone I think the poem fails. Initially I was afraid you had holed up in the john with a tattered copy of “Iron John”.
poetandknowit on bitch! by Freethinker1602 21 Oct 2003, 7:21 PM
Is this a poem or simply a collection of statements with a tag line at the end? I need to know.
Shuushin on Toku by Bill Z Bub 21 Oct 2003, 7:32 PM
Nutty and impressive (in the way that it leaves an impression). I like the unusual formatting. On the downside, I feel like there is an oversimplification, or a misunderstanding someplace; just a feeling.
Shuushin on some deleted poem 21 Oct 2003, 7:34 PM
Ack. Seeds - I hate seeds.
Shuushin on some deleted poem 21 Oct 2003, 7:42 PM
Okay - lots of really interesting and good things happening in this piece! Great imagery. The second stanza though - it just doesn't gel for me. I think you went a tad too far in the simile then the further description of how you were assembled - the whole yard gnome/lawn thing. Almost starts to sound like a bad detective novel "she was like the night, really dark and when I was around her I would always wack my shins" - okay, an extreme bad example.
Shuushin on some deleted poem 21 Oct 2003, 7:45 PM
I can hear it speaking to me, but I'm not sure what it's saying - it is interesting, but puzzling. I don't mind puzzles. As an aside, a nocturne is usually about the night - is this part of the puzzle?
poetandknowit on lame ass shit by FreeFormFixation 21 Oct 2003, 7:54 PM
See the Bitch! poem comment of using a title as a final tag line and ultimately a young cop out for a poem that would probably work better as a lyric.
some deleted user on some deleted poem 21 Oct 2003, 8:32 PM
Nice work.
xxx on some deleted poem 21 Oct 2003, 8:49 PM
:0) I was worried about that poor crab, now it's a bite. Your images are fantasic as usual. 23.49
xxx on some deleted poem 21 Oct 2003, 8:51 PM
A nice needy love poem with zing!
xxx on some deleted poem 21 Oct 2003, 8:53 PM
I liked the 4th stanza. The rest does not live up to it.
xxx on some deleted poem 21 Oct 2003, 9:01 PM
Everyone I have ever met seems to think their life worth a novel. Never know though, yours may have that quality. I'm not fond of lengthy soul pourings. Sorry, but this one made me sleepy.
xxx on some deleted poem 21 Oct 2003, 9:04 PM
Self pity shows through well, but the angst is very bland.
poetandknowit on some deleted poem 21 Oct 2003, 9:46 PM
Are you serious about this?
abecedarian on glimpses by nentwined 21 Oct 2003, 10:15 PM
I like this poem in conjunction with "sitting on a cliff's edge". The fused energy feels similar somehow. Interesting. Like two people watching the same play from different angles.
Poetry is, at its best, a 'golden section' exposed. You're pretty close to winning a bronzed chambered nautilus for this one.
abecedarian on some deleted poem 21 Oct 2003, 10:41 PM
Nice to imagine. Thank you. The originality of the metaphors actually disrupts the flow slightly on the first couple reads, but after a couple reads I don't think the metaphors are anything but nice. I think what may be a small issue is their pronounciation and how their sounds fit into the poem: e.g. buried-alive hands is a very nice descriptor but a little front loaded to mediate the spreading transmogrification.
<{Baba^Yaga}> on My Chocolate F-9 by abecedarian 21 Oct 2003, 11:15 PM
The end can be stronger! damn you.
Awesome title - now I have to read it; please hold... Hey that rocks. It's a sad and pitiful rocking, but with an air of challenges overcome.