poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 34181–34200 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

forced rhyme, stilted rhythm, and devoid of a single unique line.
This has "Hallmark" written all over it.
NanceXToo on The girl next door by Jennichad 5 Feb 2004, 1:33 PM
I think this could have been a decent poem if it had been written in a different style. Here, as is, it's just too generic, although it has a decent rhythm to it. typo on curtain. I like "she fights one here alone."
A merciless hunchback of surprise.
lastobelus replying on Tales From The Outhouse by -=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. 5 Feb 2004, 1:31 PM
Hmm, are you honestly oblivious to the skill & dexterity with language that is shown here? Go on, show me four stanzas of yours that that are this well constructed. Aber es ist mir nichts neu, that you read in vain and cannot appreciate the classique nature of this pome. Oh, and one other thing -- it's fuckin' funny.
NanceXToo on Soft Speak; Hard Emotion by Blindpoetry 5 Feb 2004, 1:28 PM
If you are truly 13, then this is actually very good for someone of that age. It does need to be cleaned up some. I just skimmed the other comments, so if I repeat anything, oh well. Stanza 1, Line 2: "Your" should be "you're." L3: I cannot see a man as a "maid." Make him someone else. The gardener. The caterer. the friggin butler. anything but maid. :-) Stanza 2, line 4 "breathe" should be "breath." Stanza 3 Line 4 "thats" needs an apostrophe. Stanza 5, line 4..it's awkward the way you went from addressing her as "you" to addressing her as "she." Stanza 6 line 1 "i" should be "I". I'm laughing at "I hope you don't mind, I fired the maid"..that's great, even though I still don't think it should be a male "maid". Other than that, the way you are attempting to show action here is awkward as well. It's not a script for a play, it's a poem, right? You need to fix that.
zodiac replying on Nina Simone (part one) by zodiac 5 Feb 2004, 1:20 PM
"You ignored my email though" - I don't know what email you're talking about. Thanks for the praise. And be cool about -=Dark_Angel=-. He's one of the best writers here.
As a sentiment, it's...nice. As a poem, it's horrid. (Sorry). Definitely too cliche, not exactly well-written, and positively boring.
NanceXToo on Nina Simone (part one) by zodiac 5 Feb 2004, 1:14 PM
Nice. I'm consistently impressed by what writing I've seen of yours. In fact, yours are among the best I've seen here (or most anywhere online lol) so far. You ignored my email though :( heh anyway this is awesome. I'd tell you my favorite parts, but I'd be quoting most of this piece back to you.
NanceXToo on 3AM At Whitey's by DurtKL 5 Feb 2004, 1:10 PM
I'm seconding what Zodiac said. :D
NanceXToo on mythical by SupremeDreamer 5 Feb 2004, 1:04 PM
This seems to be going back and forth too much between past and present tense. It could also use some cleaning up (typos and incorrectly spelled words etc.) I like "and before color could reach my cornea" and "before learning to crawl upon tiled floors." Those are the only lines that really stand out to me as 'strong' lines.
You're a very ill-mannered young lady. Now... is the door closed? A ha. I'm going to show you something that you may not like.
-=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. on A Panglossian Farmer by richa 5 Feb 2004, 12:57 PM
You certainly win the prize for the week's most aribtrary line break. The prize is six of the best followed by a trip to Matron's office.
This is cute..okay, there's some humor. Which merits it a 5. I wouldn't do more because frankly the subject matter is just utterly ridiculous. Get on your soapbox now...I can already tell you're the type :-) (I can't believe everyone gave this a 10)
NanceXToo on Unhearted by Miggy 5 Feb 2004, 12:53 PM
This isn't bad...lyric wise. I mean, i can kinda 'hear' it as a song. As a poem I'd consider it more lacking. Anyway, my only major suggestion to you is to revise your chorus because the line with the phrase "an idea stupid" is quite awkward and way too forced a rhyme.
andrewjthomas replying on Soft Speak; Hard Emotion by Blindpoetry 5 Feb 2004, 11:47 AM
mmmmm, suicidegirls.com, mmmmmmm
-=Dark_Angel=-, P.I. replying on Emily Mae by horus8 5 Feb 2004, 11:42 AM
bow'ls
andrewjthomas on Emily Mae by horus8 5 Feb 2004, 11:41 AM
what goad said still, nice job over all
andrewjthomas replying on La Belle Epoque by andrewjthomas 5 Feb 2004, 11:25 AM
still not done with editing, going through each "section" already removed the stranger in a strange land line, way too cheap (i posted my very first draft, which is my only excuse for that) all other good comments... and i may reverse the breaks, it's an experiment tweaking........
<{Baba^Yaga}> replying on Emily Mae by horus8 5 Feb 2004, 11:23 AM
I have Strunk and White, pink dot, and all the time in the world my dear friend. Thank you for the -edit- you're so Ace. "Bathetic" Yes, lol, but I've seen worse shit go down.