poemranker ::Comments the most recent

CommentsComments 65221–65240 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

Katie on Curse by OneFingerAnswer 13 Sep 2002, 8:54 AM
=) I like it, not complicated, but yet it's still a wonderfull poem, cootos!! 9/10 =)
Limness on she wonders, by <~> 13 Sep 2002, 8:48 AM
Dreamy, and painful--now that i've read the comments. Hang in there; lots of fish in the sea (I know you don't want to hear that, but give it some time, dear, give it some time.)
poetandknowit on Mermaid at Dawn by <~> 13 Sep 2002, 8:44 AM
Why the .... Sexy and I like the last line.
god'swife on Our New Tongue by Christof 13 Sep 2002, 8:42 AM
Excellent. Hadn't read this before. "Oaths of faith and love" Please work on writing a new contract for all the girls and boys. I love stanza 4, awkward and sad without being awkward and sad. Is she married?
Katie on fairy tale by jlanza 13 Sep 2002, 8:39 AM
It could use a little work, the idea is nice, but the structer could use some work. 7/10 =)
Katie on Come Back to Me by jlanza 13 Sep 2002, 8:38 AM
!! love it, it's cute, but not complicated, there's some parts I would fix, but besides that I love it! 9/10!! =)
Funny or goofy? Hmmm. that is a tough one. Any way biker Frass, lol, 52 weeks a year. Did you visit the girls specifically or did you just happen to be on the veranda and visit "with" them. The nervous laughter and looks makes me think this is spontaneous which throws the title out of context and bothers me. Plus, it sounds just trite. Is this like the first time you have ever encountered anybody outside of your shell. I bet you just love seeing boys in lycra, muscles bulging, sweat pouring, pounding Gary Fisher pedals 52 weeks a year. ummm. Yummy. When I cum out to VA will you be my bitch?
Katie on Oh Well III by RWAndersen 13 Sep 2002, 8:36 AM
I like the flow, but like the last line, maybe change it a little. But the rest, basically, I liked =) 9/10
Katie on Satisfaction by Ojiboch 13 Sep 2002, 8:33 AM
over all it pretty good, try to add more detail =)
Katie on she wonders, by <~> 13 Sep 2002, 8:29 AM
Um...WTF!! spoon her. yeah..okay
<~> on pissed off pretentious prat by keatsImnot 13 Sep 2002, 8:06 AM
nice, but exile/all alone is redundant... uzwyze, nice job
<~> on Full Fathom Five by vulcan 13 Sep 2002, 7:57 AM
this is good, vulcan. may i make a few suggestions, to tighten it up?
Katie on None by poemreader 13 Sep 2002, 6:44 AM
=)
=)
Christof replying on Like and Unlike by Christof 13 Sep 2002, 3:35 AM
Confusion in this case is good! I decided to subvert myself a bit. And 'tone' - I need a rhyme for 'xylophone' and it makes me think of a clinical description, which I like for this poem. I read thos one myself and thought 'this is a bit odd'.
Christof replying on Like and Unlike by Christof 13 Sep 2002, 3:31 AM
'Dully' is an adverb - the unknown meets the unknown in a dully way. It's a good word aurally, but I admit it looks a bit peculiar on paper.(or screen). Also I know what you mean about moths, but I liked the implied fragility of the butterfly wing that for me the moth doesn't have. What an abstruse distinction to have to make. And we have some very mottled and drab butterflies in England.
Christof on Full Fathom Five by vulcan 13 Sep 2002, 3:21 AM
I like your turning to literature for comfort and finding some salvation there. 'gray Elegy' also brings to mind Thomas Gray's 'Elegy in a Country Churchyard' - is this deliberate?
This is funny - I especially like your last couple of lines.
Christof replying on Gone Away by Christof 13 Sep 2002, 1:13 AM
If only!
You know, if you're going to get way up there on your giant soap box you should at least make it pretty. This is not a poem It's a very bad nagging session. "Is this what makes us proud?" "Is this what our ancestors...." You sound like a crotchety old man. An impact can never be made by standing and wagging your finger.