poemranker ::20 most recent comments by Christof (21-40) and replies

Comments byChristof, 21–40 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

on On and On and On by MacFrantic 11 Jul 2007, 6:31 AM
I agree, this is too long and repetitious and inventing a word like 'diers' to enforce a rhyme just isn't on. 'I'm a headache in the head/Of an infantile cupid' is tautologous - where else would the Cupid have a headache? Really, this has no focus but misery.
replying on Summer Loving by Christof 6 Jul 2007, 1:22 AM
I like twisted! I'm sorry to say I'm not interested in her POV in this - it's all about the voyeurs on the platform. Thanks for your comment though.
on (Title pending) by INTRANSIT 5 Jul 2007, 7:13 AM
Hey, I still like cochlea. This seems a little less sensuous than it did before - I'm not sure what other changes have been made - but it seems to me smoother and less memorable. I wouldn't have changed it. But you can't please all the people all the time...
on What the log book doesn't show by INTRANSIT 5 Jul 2007, 7:09 AM
Stanza 6 is great - I love a judiciously used pun. I think the last stanza also sums the whole up very poignantly. I'm afraid I don't know what an EKG is, so I'm not sure if I entirely get stanza 2, though the meaning is clear, but generally I think this is one of the best things I've read on this site.
replying on Summer Festival by Christof 2 Jul 2007, 9:12 AM
Actually, that's quite a serious allegation in Poemrankerland. I'd like to know why you said that.
replying on Summer Festival by Christof 2 Jul 2007, 9:09 AM
Er... I didn't. How could I? I don't think the site even allows you to do that, does it?
replying on Summer Festival by Christof 2 Jul 2007, 3:31 AM
Interesting - I can't see where to punctuate this without interrupting the flow of the thing. Suggestions?
on A Flower for Monet by Shuushin 27 Jun 2007, 6:29 AM
I commented before but never voted - here you go. I think end slightly lets it down, too limpid, too unearned, but the piece reads beautifully. Is the 'orange sun' over the Seine in the second stanza a reference to a Monet painting - is that the connection?
on Kittens and Pocket Money by Shuushin 27 Jun 2007, 6:17 AM
For once I can agree with Rockmage. It's probably what everyone on this site, in fact everyone everywhere, really wants and you have put it beautifully.
on (Title pending) by INTRANSIT 27 Jun 2007, 6:00 AM
Hi - good to see you again! Like this a lot. 'Cochlea' is a strangely anatomical word to use, it makes me feel almost queasy, and I think that's good - shows just how far those women burrow into us, even though we'd like to pretend they don't. A good tension between that and the last stanza. Nice one.
replying on Foie Gras by Christof 25 Jun 2007, 1:38 AM
The 'funnel' is my own term, glad you like it! And the geese are referring back to the title - they are the telesales people being filled up until they burst, like geese fattened up to make pate de foie gras.
replying on grim task by lmp 21 Jun 2007, 2:46 PM
By 'our most pompus novelists' I was referring to British novelists - I was comparing Brits to de Lillo and and Lewis. But as I said, there's no pomposity monopoly on either side. I don't know where 'lorry' comes from, but it's definitely different to a truck. A truck is smaller and cuter.
on grim task by lmp 21 Jun 2007, 7:35 AM
The villanelle is tough little nut to crack and i think this pretty damn good. I don't really like 'ev'ry' - I think the metre would make the syllabic count of the word clear, and it would be nice not to have that archaism. But it's only a small thing and it's made up for by 'wet silty clay' - you've obviously been digging in my garden. Not wanting to get pulled into the British pomposity argument above but - really, the Brits don't have the monopoly on pomposity. Our most pompous novelists are laugh riots next to Dom de Lillo or Sinclair Lewis and as for linguistic rigidity - have you seen the New Yorker? It's like Edith Wharton never died.
on Just Another Reason by Skamper 21 Jun 2007, 6:48 AM
Do you have kids? This does sound like the conversation a parent has with himself whenever the darling child misbehaves. A typo in 'offspring' but otherwise I like this, it's a good bit of polemic.
replying on Field Work by Christof 21 Jun 2007, 5:42 AM
I've been inspired to get up off my arse recently, for some reason. Possibly having a new baby. And of course the best thing to do is come straight back here and have a ruck with Rockmage, but never mind. Glad you liked this and yes, it is about something a bit naughty.
on Bookends by INTRANSIT 19 Jun 2007, 4:04 AM
This is really new from you! This like Ezra Pound meets Lenny Bruce - really enjoyable and funny and letting its satirical teeth gleam. It's good to be abck on the 'ranker. The end of a very long dry spell has brought me back and it's good to see old friends here.
on Eleven Reasons For Love by horus8 19 Jun 2007, 4:01 AM
Horus

It's been a long time since I last came here and some of the old timers have gone - where is God'swife's poetry? - but how good to see you're still here, still spitting it out according to your own personal rhythm - I like it.
on The first time in forever by Jeremi B. Handrinos 29 Jan 2007, 8:34 AM
This is great - controlled, wry, well-paced, dispassionate but bursting with sadness. Lovely lovely stuff.
The problems with this could all be sorted out by substituting the word 'ISRAEL' with the word 'NEWPORT PAGNELL'.
on The Passing by Stephen Robins 29 Jan 2007, 8:27 AM
This made me laugh. That is a good thing.