poemranker ::20 most recent comments by Shuushin (261-280) and replies

Comments byShuushin, 261–280 back, including replies. Only comments on poems

on Rosalía de Castro: When I was born by Sasha 21 Jun 2004, 6:00 PM
what you think about using "spake" instead of "spoke"?

I think "daggar" s/b "dagger" unless you a punning a character (it could happen!)


nice one.
on Drunk and Fucked Up by wilco 21 Jun 2004, 5:57 PM
great hook with seranade

I don't like the verb agreement here:
"Shake the spiders from my mind
and let it eat me up inside."

I know that you could mean "it" is something else, but its not intuitive - save the trouble of deciphering and make the quantities agree, imho.
on 5/22 by aburiedlife 21 Jun 2004, 5:55 PM
one of the better free-form pimples in a while.

on Sonnetias by MacFrantic 21 Jun 2004, 5:54 PM
L4 try:
"A craving deepened by our thoughts of past"

L9:
"Just ask again and you'll encounter scorn"

not too shabby, not too shabby at all. An extra bit for a sonnet.


on Navy Pier by Doug 19 Jun 2004, 9:00 AM
Hey doug, this has a very honest feel to it.

Let me pick at it a bit too, hopefully focusing on things you might use in other poems.

the word "can" just takes up space, really it does't convey anything except as a noun.

And "still" - same thing.

LEt me give you one more thing to think about. This saying you hear LMich and actually using the word "hear" - also not a big value adding word in this context.

Suppose you had done instead

Lake Michigan
soft and stoic, cobalt breakers
lilted Beer Garden breezes ... [etc.]

See, the same thing is conveyed but without the burden of those words; it's [I hope] more showing than telling. Why make the reader work if they get nothing in return?

But even without that stuff, this still has a very sweet feel.
on 0 by MacFrantic 18 Jun 2004, 4:27 AM
what is "Oh snap" mean?
on Origins by Doug 18 Jun 2004, 4:24 AM
The only complaint I have, and its more of an observation - is that the players seem somewhat arbitary.

I mean why not "Desperation" or "Futility" or "Esctacy" (etc.)?

The title alone doesn't serve well enough to establish the setting.
on Paid In Full by NoSage 16 Jun 2004, 7:33 PM
father's day?
replying on Origins by Doug 16 Jun 2004, 2:06 PM
Don't feel bad Doug, we don't know what he's saying half the time either.
on Dealer (a senyru) by Mona Lisa 15 Jun 2004, 3:25 PM
EXCELLENT. and you even called it the right name!
replying on Big wave by DR Limerick 15 Jun 2004, 2:38 PM
Thank you, good doctor.
on Thin Blood by Rodavlas 15 Jun 2004, 10:19 AM
take the second half of the second verse and put the rest back into the word-pile.

And the last line could work too - just the idea of it; toasting bodyparts.

could make a memorable song - but not another suicide note.
on The Stickmen of Fools by embersandenvelopes 14 Jun 2004, 10:12 AM
Reads fairly well - not entirely sure what it's about though. Feels like a venting somehow.

I like this idea of pouncing on something then the pouncer suffocating.
on Hiding by QuirkyWonder 13 Jun 2004, 2:50 PM
ahhhh, dat's chute.
on Big wave by DR Limerick 13 Jun 2004, 2:45 PM
There once was a woman from Taigan
Who drew one hell of a floorplan
She met a man by shore
Though she found him a bore
He paid her again and again.


on Lost by arduinn 12 Jun 2004, 8:44 AM
This would be better for a verb tense sweep.

"Often I sit alone and wondered"

"What does he has that Dad didn't?"

stuff like that.
replying on Untitled 48 by TLRufener 12 Jun 2004, 8:22 AM
Btw - I bet you could do this with less than half the words. I don't mean this as a dig in anyway, but after reading all of your poems (here, and there) I really think it would make them stronger.

(please, don't throw that shoe)
on Untitled 48 by TLRufener 12 Jun 2004, 8:16 AM
Ahah! I know what it is! it is a "riddle". Or it could also be a pen.
on Fool by arduinn 11 Jun 2004, 8:26 PM
Wow. This one is getting lots of traffic, isn't it? Never a bad thing.

I'd like to see this expanded; fleshed out a bit - and it will be better for it.
on fire has its own logic by impert&ent 11 Jun 2004, 4:53 PM
"interiority of computers" - interesting.

Some fresh ideas here, but the form is hurting it imho; got me thinking on it.